Being Caucasian in an Asian Body
Updated: Oct 1
Before you read this blog post, I want to note that I have had and still am having an overall good life. I am surrounded by people I love. With that being said, I have experienced things regarding my race while living in America ever since I was young. This is not a post hating on all Caucasian people. This post is not me stating my life is the worst. This post is not trying to showcase that Asians get the most hate compared to other groups. This post is simply intended to give others insight into what it's like being an adopted woman from China who grew up and is still living in America so that others are aware that racism is still very much prevalent so we can all work towards creating a world where not just equality but also equity is available for all regardless of their race and their background. Now that I have stated my disclaimer... please get a snack and get comfy and I hope you enjoy the post! :)
"No, where are you really from?"
Depending on who you are, that question may trigger you or you may not have much thought about it. That is one of the several questions that non-Caucasian individuals will get asked in the United States, including me. People have asked me where I am from ever since I was little. My answer always goes straight to Indiana since I have lived there most of my life. However, this answer isn't sufficient enough for some. Some will go one step further and ask me, "No, where are you really from?". They aren't looking at a girl who was adopted when she was only one year old and has resided in the U.S. ever since. They aren't looking at a girl who has only ever known a life in the U.S. and is an American citizen. They are looking at a girl who is clearly Asian. They are expecting me to tell them I am from China. Afterward, those people usually don't want to know me past that as I have finally given them the correct answer. Even though being Asian is a major part of me, it is not all of me. Some may argue that these people are just trying to get to know me but I could easily counteract by asking, "Does looking at someone's physical appearance and finding out where their genetic make-up resides really tell you everything about that individual?". The simple answer is no.
History of Anti-Asian Racism in America
"The FBI has documented a 77% increase from 2019 to 2020 in hate crimes against Asian people living in the U.S." (Findling et al., 2022)
Before I go over some of my own experiences of racism, I wanted to highlight that racism against Asian people in the United States is nothing new. It has been around a long time but it has not been talked about as much compared to other races until recent years. Listed below are a few, but not all, instances in American history regarding racism among Asians.
People vs Hall (1854)
Many Chinese immigrants started coming to the U.S. in the 1850s within the Western area of America including California. These individuals instantly faced discrimination and violence. These immigrants would work low-wage, dangerous jobs such as mining and railroad construction. However, Americans were automatically assuming that Asians were coming to the U.S. to take all of their jobs.
In 1854, George Hall, a Caucasian American, shot and murdered Ling Sing, a Chinese immigrant. This case is significant as the California Supreme Court stated that people who are of Asian descent could not testify against a Caucasian person in court. A person who witnessed the incident and wanted to provide testimony were not allowed as they were Asian and not Caucasian.
Chinese Massacre in California (1871)
On October 24, 1871, two Chinese groups were fighting each other in Los Angeles, California. During this fight, a Caucasian man was killed in the crossfire. Because of the man's death, more than 500 Caucasian and Hispanic individuals banded together to surround and attack a small Chinese community that was located in a red-light district which was known as Negro Alley. It was reported that at least 18 Chinese men and boys were hung to death by noose throughout various places. Only eight of the group members that attacked were convicted of manslaughter. However, those eight members had their convictions overturned and no one else was punished.
Chinese Exclusion Act (1882)
The Chinese Exclusion Act is known to be the first significant law in American history that limits immigrants entering the United States. It was passed in the spring of 1882 by Congress and signed by President Chester A. Arthur. The act allowed a legal 10-year ban on Chinese labor immigration. Following this ban, it was re-established for another 10 years in 1892. Then it was permanently established in 1902. However, it was repealed in 1943.
Although this act allowed non-labor Chinese immigrants to come to the U.S., it was not an easy process. These non-labor immigrants needed to obtain a certificate from the Chinese government to migrate to the U.S. Obtaining one of these certificates was hard due to proving their status. This explains why not many Chinese immigrants came to America at this time. Additionally, Congress refused state and federal courts the right to grant citizenship to Chinese immigrants who were already residing in America when this act occurred. However, the courts did have the right to deport these residing citizens.
Japanese Interment Camps (1942)
During World War II, Pearl Harbor was bombed by Japan. This event made many Americans suspicious of Japanese individuals in the United States as they thought these individuals were spies and would aid those in Japan. President Franklin Roosevelt decided to force almost 120,000 Japanese people residing in the U.S. into internment camps for the remainder of the war, regardless of their citizenship status. These people only had a few days to pack and prepare what they were about to face. Within the camps, it was known to be harsh living conditions. The summers were reported to be very hot and the winters very cold. When the Japanese individuals returned from the camps, many of their homes and businesses were vandalized or confiscated. Those who were of Japanese descent were seen as disloyal and traitors. However, in the end, there was no report of any spies found. It is important to highlight that those who experienced the camps and were still alive in 1988 received an apology from the president and $20,000 each.
Murder of Vincent Chin (1982)
On June 19, 1982, Vincent Chin, a 27-year-old Chinese American, was out drinking with his friends in celebration of his upcoming wedding. Two Caucasian men, Ronald Ebens and Michael Nitz, started a fight with Chin. They blamed Chin for the Japanese who were "taking" their auto-industry jobs as they mistook him for a Japanese individual. They beat him with a baseball bat outside of the bar which was the cause of his death four days later. They were convicted of manslaughter but ultimately got probation and a $3,000 fine.
The Corona Virus (2020)
One of the most recent situations regarding racism against Asians and Asian Americans is COVID-19. The virus was originally detected in China before it spread. Since it was first detected in China, many people have blamed Asians and Asian Americans for the virus. To put it into perspective, between March 2020 and June 2021, the organization, STOP AAPI HATE, received more than 9,000 self-reports of incidents regarding racism, hate speech, discrimination, and physical attacks against Asians and Asian Americans. You must remember that there are always statistically more people who do not report incidents compared to those who do. Additionally, America was not the only country that was participating in racism and discrimination against Asian descent during this time. Other participating countries include the United Kingdom, Russia, Australia, India, and Sri Lanka.
I will not go into how many issues and negative situations have occurred towards Asians and Asian Americans due to the global pandemic. However, if you simply look up "Asian racism COVID" on Google, there are many articles, news reports, and research journals that will show you just how much the pandemic has given a target on Asian and Asian Americans' backs.
My Personal Experiences with Racism
I tend to joke with my friends that most days I feel like I am a Caucasian woman in an Asian body.
To give some background context for those who may not know me or my story, I was adopted when I was one year old from China by two loving parents. My parents are Caucasian. One is from Iowa and the other is from Illinois. My two brothers are also adopted but from Romania. One could pass as Caucasian and one could not. When I was adopted and brought back to the United States, I became an American citizen when I stepped foot on American soil due to the Child Citizenship Act of 2000. I grew up with mostly Caucasian people in my life and was surrounded by American culture. My best friends, my classmates, my co-workers, my boyfriend, and my family are all in the majority of being Caucasian. I tend to joke with my friends that most days I feel like I am a Caucasian woman in an Asian body.
When you grow up in American culture surrounded by mostly Caucasian people, it can be easy to feel like you are just another American Caucasian girl. You go to the same schools as everyone else. You wear the same clothes as everyone else. You speak the same language just as good as everyone else. You have the same hobbies as everyone else. You morph into that culture. But on the outside, you are not what you're surrounded by. You appear as an Asian girl because you are an Asian girl from China. When you were younger, you thought, "I wish I could have pretty blonde hair and blue eyes". But you will never have those features naturally because God doesn't make Asian people with Caucasian features (unless they genetically have Caucasian in them which you don't have). You learn over time that people will ask where you're really from and they want an answer based on your appearance. You learn that people will make assumptions about you regarding your appearance instead of getting to know you. They will think you watch anime and speak Chinese but become disappointed when you say you don't do either of those things. You will compare yourself to your Caucasian friends whose eyelashes curl more than yours and who seem to catch boys' attention more than you do. You will see people on social media and be like, "Why don't I look like that?" and then you remember you're not Caucasian but Chinese. You won't have much Asian representation in movies and TV shows besides Mulan when you are young since it is the early 2000s and that representation won't be shown until around the 2020s when you're a legal adult. You will learn that there are stereotypes that people will abide by but the stereotypes are "good", so you should be happy about it... right? You will learn that people will speak fake Chinese to you and pull back their eyes but they're close to you so you have to laugh as if it's a funny joke and that it secretly doesn't hurt. You will learn that no one close to you will experience what you have experienced because none of them are Asian.
On April 16, 2019, my mom and I decided to go and get pedicures. We both are not ones for always getting our nails done professionally as we will usually paint our nails ourselves. However, every now and then, especially on special occasions, we will go and get pedicures together. This was one of those special occasions as I was about to graduate high school. We went to one of the local nail salons in our area. It was a nice, sunny day and I was feeling great. I love spending time with my mom since I grew up with two older brothers and I can just be a girl with her. We walked into the salon and we were told to pick out which colors we wanted our toes to be painted. While I was looking at the endless options, a Caucasian lady seemed to state that she was going to use the restroom and she would be right back. I figured she was talking to one of the workers since I was too busy looking at the colors. But my mom was able to see that the lady was talking to me as if I worked there since "all Asian people work in nail salons". I was so confused about how this lady could have mistaken me for a nail technician as I was an 18-year-old girl dressed in teal shorts, a light grey sweater, and flip-flops picking out a nail color who hadn't talked to her prior. This is one of the few instances in which I had experienced stereotypes based on my outer appearance.
Another area that my race has played a pretty big part is the dating scene. Now, many know I am not one for exposing my dating life to the masses as well as who I talk to as I do like to keep that pretty private. However, some may wonder, "Em, what does your race have to do with dating?". I don't think many think about what non-Caucasians experience while trying to find their "forever." There have been many boys, not men, that I talk to who expect me to be this Asian dream girl who watches anime, speaks Chinese, drinks boba, and eats ramen all day. And although I do love my boba and ramen and have occasionally watched two or three anime movies, I am not what they think of when they want to date an Asian girl. A lot of them like to tell me how they've never been with an Asian girl before as if dating my race gives me some type of new powers and experiences for them that another race can not give them. When I date, I have to remember that any contender who isn't Asian will ultimately end with me having a mixed-race kid and I have to think about how my future, potential children will struggle with their race because they are genetically made up of two races which may make them unsure of where they fit in this world. I also have to make sure that no one I talked to was only dating me because of my race and they don't have a weird fetish for Asian girls (I really wish this part was a lie).
One time in the spring of 2023, I was out with my best friend, Monette. We were at a bar/club in our hometown just being 22 years old. While we were on the dance floor, a guy started to talk to me. Since I knew that Monette fancied his friend and I didn't want to be rude, I agreed talk to him. It was too loud to talk verbally so we talked back and forth on his phone's notes app. We introduced ourselves and he started flirting with me. He told me that he thought I was cute and proceeded to tell me how he doesn't date Caucasian women. Since I was curious, I asked why didn't he date Caucasian women. He told me, I wish I was joking, that he thinks Caucasian women look like guys and they aren't as nice as non-Caucasian women. He has not been the first guy to say how non-Caucasian women are nicer as it is another thing I have heard quite often among potential past prospects. (Side note: I told this story to another one of my best friends, Anna, and she said that non-Caucasian women, like me, are probably nicer because we get discriminated against a lot more. I am simply leaving this in here because I think there is some truth in what Anna said and I think some people will find the humor in it the way I have).
The last and most recent case that I will touch on was during Monette's birthday this past month. During her birthday, I went to celebrate with her family and close friend. While I was there, they brought up the current concerns around China and the spies that have been taking place. I kept thinking about how even though I am not a spy for China, have lived in the U.S. pretty much my entire life, and I have no ties in China, this will probably affect me. Those who do not know me but see that I am Chinese can easily start treating me a certain way due to their speculations on my physical exterior. Some of you may think that this is a stretch but in my experience, it is not. When COVID-19 was in full swing, I would get looks from strangers as if I went to China and brought back the virus myself. Even though they did not know me and I have not been to China since eighth grade, my outer appearance screamed Asian and they based how they reacted on that alone.
I could go on and on talking about racism and my personal experiences as well as the many points in history where it is shown that Asian people are discriminated against. But that is not the main focus of this blog post. I hope that with this blog post, I have given some, if not, at least one of you insight into what it is like to be Asian in America currently and growing up. How people like me have faced racism and stereotypes since we were young and how future generations of Asians and Asian Americans will most likely experience what I and my ancestors have experienced/are still experiencing today. How there needs to be more awareness about discrimination and racism regarding those who are Asian. And most importantly, how it is crucial to not just base your assumptions on what people look like. We all contribute to the world whether we want to or not, so let's contribute positivity and kindness to others.
"The best thing you can do today is to speak out against violence towards Asians in this country, espeically if you yourself are not Asian."- George Takei
Thanks for reading! I hope you enjoyed the blog! Don't forget to subscribe so you don't miss a new blog post. Feel free to reach out with ideas, feedback, business inquiries, etc. For further reading and information on racism towards Asian Americans as well as donating and helping those who are Asian and experiencing racism/discrimination, check out the websites below.
For Further Learning, Donating, and Helping Asian Americans Against Racism and Discrimination
References Used For Blog
References Used
Brockell, G. (2021, March 18). The long, ugly history of anti-Asian racism and violence in the U.S. Washington Post. Retrieved March 28, 2024, from https://www.washingtonpost.com/history/2021/03/18/history-anti-asian-violence-racism/
Chinese Exclusion Act (1882). (2023, January 17). National Archives. Retrieved March 28, 2024, from https://www.archives.gov/milestone-documents/chinese-exclusion-act#:~:text=It%20was%20the%20first%20significant,immigrating%20to%20the%20United%20States.
COVID-19 fueling Anti-Asian racism and xenophobia worldwide. (2020, May 12). Human Rights Watch. Retrieved March 28, 2024, from https://www.hrw.org/news/2020/05/12/covid-19-fueling-anti-asian-racism-and-xenophobia-worldwide
Findling, M. G., Blendon, R. J., Benson, J., & Koh, H. (2022). COVID-19 has driven racism and violence against Asian Americans: Perspectives from 12 national polls [Dataset]. In Health Affairs Forefront. https://doi.org/10.1377/forefront.20220411.655787
Hohman, M. (2021, March 8). Anti-Asian violence has surged in the US since COVID-19. But it didn’t start there. TODAY. Retrieved March 28, 2024, from https://www.today.com/news/anti-asian-violence-history-anti-asian-racism-us-t210645

Comments